If eating gluten makes you feel bloated, fatigued, or nauseous or gives you brain fog, diarrhea, constipation, or abdominal pain, it’s possible that you may have gluten sensitivity. However, people who have celiac disease share these same symptoms.
In this blog post, we’ll cover the difference between non-celiac gluten sensitivity vs. celiac disease, how each are diagnosed, and functional medicine treatments that can help you take charge of your health once again.
What Is Gluten Sensitivity?
In gluten sensitivity—also known as gluten intolerance or non-celiac gluten sensitivity—the body has an immune reaction to gluten, a protein found in grains like wheat, barley, and rye. This is not an autoimmune reaction, but it creates an inflammatory response. A gluten sensitivity is an immune reaction to the protein structure of gluten. The mechanism still is not fully understood, but it involves an inflammatory response to gluten. Unlike celiac disease, this is not an autoimmune reaction. There is no diagnostic test for gluten sensitivity, which is why most people do a gluten elimination to test for it. We discuss this later, under “Gluten Sensitivity vs. Celiac Disease Lab Test.” Exposure to gluten is creating an immunoglobulin-G (IgG) or immunoglobulin -A (IgA) type of delayed hypersensitivity response.
Immunoglobulins are antibodies. Their presence after exposure to gluten indicates the body is having an immune response to gluten. This is not the type of allergic reaction that causes anaphylactic shock and it does not lead to destruction of the gut tissue as you would have in celiac disease. IgG and IgA responses are more of a chronic response that can occur hours after eating gluten or other sensitive foods.
What Is Celiac Disease?
In celiac disease, eating gluten triggers an autoimmune response in the gut lining, which causes damage and destruction directly to the microvilli that absorb nutrients in the small intestine. Celiac disease is an autoimmune disorder that causes the immune system to mistakenly attack the body’s own tissues.
Celiac disease is commonly seen alongside other autoimmune diseases. People with celiac disease have a higher risk of Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, type 1 diabetes, rheumatoid arthritis, and more. That’s why we look closely at gluten reactions in all of our practice members with autoimmunity.
Is Gluten Intolerance the Same as Celiac Disease?
No, gluten intolerance is not the same as celiac disease. However, there are some similarities. In both conditions, you react poorly when you eat gluten. They are both driven by the immune system, which creates an inflammatory response. However, in celiac disease the inflammatory response causes autoimmune damage to the small intestines whereas in gluten sensitivity, it is more of a systemic immune response.
People with celiac disease must remain on a strict gluten-free diet, whereas people with non-celiac gluten sensitivity may be able to eat some gluten, especially if they work on resolving the root causes of their sensitivity.
Gluten Sensitivity vs. Celiac Disease Lab Test
Celiac Disease Tests
One difference between celiac disease and gluten intolerance is how the conditions are diagnosed. For celiac disease, blood markers, antibody testing, and genetic tests are used to diagnose the condition. One blood test can help diagnose celiac disease. It is the IgA antibody to tissue transglutaminase (tTG) test.
Tests are available to determine if somebody is more genetically susceptible to developing celiac. However, even if you have the genes, it doesn’t guarantee you’re going to have celiac. And you can have celiac without the genes.
For that reason, physicians looking for celiac disease will order an upper endoscopy and take a biopsy (tissue sample) of the small intestine to find out how much damage has been done to the gut lining. This is a more dependable way to confirm the presence of celiac disease.
The Marsh scale grades the level of damage in the small intestine from celiac disease using a biopsy sample. A lower level indicates inflammation in the lining and may suggest celiac disease. Higher stages like Marsh 3 identify significant damage of the villi and flattening, called “villous atrophy,” usually pointing to a definitive celiac diagnosis.
Gluten Sensitivity Tests
Celiac disease testing is more well understood than testing for gluten sensitivity. There is no diagnostic test for gluten sensitivity yet. For gluten sensitivity, the diagnosis can be as simple as eliminating gluten from your diet. See if you feel better without it. Then add it back. If the symptoms return, there’s a high likelihood it’s gluten intolerance. An elimination diet is still the gold standard for figuring out if you have a sensitivity response.
Another piece of helpful information is a food sensitivity test to find out if you’re having an IgG immune reaction to gluten. I recommend the Cyrex lab test, which tests for IgG and IgA reactions.
Eating Gluten Before Testing
Another important consideration of lab testing is that if you stop eating gluten before testing for celiac or a gluten sensitivity, it can skew the results of the testing. If we are going to test somebody for a sensitivity, they have to be consuming that food for at least two weeks prior to doing the test. If you aren’t eating a food at all, the results show no reaction because your immune system isn’t coming into contact with the food.
The same thing happens with celiac testing. Doctors will tell the patients, “If you haven’t been eating gluten, you need to go back to eating it before we can test you to see if it’s positive for celiac.” At that point, especially if somebody is suspecting they have celiac, and they’re feeling so much better without eating gluten, most people don’t want to go through the process of adding it back in to get the diagnosis. Adding it back in isn’t worth the suffering just to get the diagnosis.
Is Celiac Disease Just Gluten Free?
In dealing with our practice members, we typically see that it’s not just gluten that people are reacting to. Celiac is a gluten-specific reaction, but when somebody has celiac-damage in their gut lining, a lot of times they will also be reacting to other foods. This occurs because of all the damage to the gut lining and the immune system being in this high-alert state.
The immune system can confuse other foods that are similar enough to gluten. These are what we call cross-reactive foods that have a similar structure to gluten. Dairy is a common food that people with celiac should avoid. Even other gluten-free grains can cause a similar reaction because they’re structurally similar enough in their proteins. For this reason, foods like gluten-free oats can still cause a reaction.
This also happens in a gluten-sensitivity response. Whatever was causing the person to develop the immune reaction in the first place can be causing them to react to other foods as well.
What Causes Gluten Sensitivity?
There are common reasons why you may become sensitive to a food—including gluten. Digestive issues are one of the most common reasons. If you’re not digesting food, you’re not breaking it down into the nutrients that the body recognizes as normal. And so, the food looks foreign when it’s presented to the immune system, and the immune system attacks it. That’s what causes an immune reaction.
Poor digestion can be caused by low stomach acid or not enough pancreatic enzymes or other gut enzymes. This can lead to food sensitivities like gluten sensitivity because you’re not digesting your food.
Another cause of food sensitivities could be the gut lining isn’t as healthy as it should be. This can be from chronic inflammation of the gut lining, possibly arising from bacterial overgrowth. Other causes of leaky gut include antibiotic use, alcohol, chronic use of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory medications like ibuprofen, and more. Imbalances can cause gut issues that lead to food sensitivities.
Eating a restricted diet for too long can lead to lack of diversity, which is another cause of gluten sensitivity and food sensitivities. Lack of diversity affects the microbiome, which can lead to leaky gut problems. If the gut lining is leaky or too permeable, then more foods get exposed to the immune system than they normally would. At this point, the immune system reacts as if there’s a threat and that causes a reaction.
Eating too much of a particular food can also contribute to food sensitivities. The foods that you eat most often are the biggest culprits. For example, if you eat eggs every single day, you could have a higher chance of reacting to eggs just because you have more exposure. If your diet’s not diverse enough, and you’re eating too many of the same things over and over again, then potentially you can develop more sensitivities to those foods.
What Causes Celiac Disease?
While we don’t know for sure what triggers celiac disease, we do know that more people are suffering from this condition than ever before. Since the second half of the 20th century into the 21st century, the incidence of celiac disease has risen in nearly every country where data is available. Over the last several decades, incidence rates increased by an average of 7.5% per year.
One theory for the increased celiac disease prevalence is the hybridization of wheat. It contains even more gluten and has a different protein structure than it did 30 years ago.
Celiac Disease and Gluten Sensitivity Treatments
With celiac disease, you’ll need to eat gluten-free forever. You’ll need to be careful that the foods you’re eating aren’t cross-contaminated with gluten. As little as 10 mg per day of gluten—the amount found in a crumb of bread— can cause damage to the small intestines.
With gluten sensitivity, you might be able to tolerate some gluten if we identify and fix the reasons why you’re reacting to gluten in the first place, whether the problem is with your digestion or gut lining. You might not have to be on a strict gluten-free diet long-term. If we can figure out why your immune system was reacting to gluten in the first place, eating gluten from time to time may not flare you up.
For either celiac disease or gluten intolerance, the goal is to figure out what’s contributing to the problem. It’s not just about cutting out gluten, but also figuring out why the immune system is in that state. Like with all autoimmune diseases, we need to figure out the root causes of why your immune system is behaving abnormally in celiac disease, where any excess inflammation is coming from, and other factors that are triggering the immune system.
The treatment needs to be aligned with the root cause. That is why stool testing is helpful. We want to understand what’s not working well in someone’s gut. That way, we’re not just throwing treatments at the gut, but we’re really tailoring the treatments to that person’s individual needs.
With celiac, it’s an autoimmune disease, so we want to understand drivers of autoimmunity. But even with somebody that has just a gluten sensitivity (which is not an autoimmune disease), we want to look at what else may be keeping their immune system in a higher state of alert, causing it to be more reactive. With both celiac disease and gluten sensitivity, the goal is to look for the root causes and then apply the right tools.
Those tools might include elimination and reintroduction diets to figure out what you don’t tolerate outside of just gluten. We want to make sure your diet ends up being as diverse as possible to help feed the microbiome and heal your gut. Diet diversity is ultimately the goal for both cases instead of just restriction.
Best Supplements for Gluten Sensitivity and Celiac Disease
The best supplements for celiac disease and gluten intolerance can vary from person to person, depending upon the root causes of your problem. However, as a general rule, most people with either of these conditions can benefit from a digestive enzyme supplement. You’ll want to look for a supplement that contains the gluten-digesting enzyme, dipeptidyl peptidase IV (DPP-4), which can help the body cope with occasional intake of gluten in people who have gluten sensitivity. Apex Energetics RepairVite-SE™ is a good enzyme and gut health blend. Because celiac disease can cause nutrient absorption problems, a multivitamin is also a good idea.
Functional Medicine, Gluten Sensitivity, and Celiac Disease
A lot of conventional medicine practitioners still don’t really believe in gluten sensitivity. And even with celiac disease, which is very well characterized, a lot of our practice members who have seen gastroenterologists are not told about diet or nutrition other than not to eat gluten. They’re not told that there are other foods they could be reacting to that are similar to gluten. They’re not told about supporting their gut, or that they have an autoimmune disease and there are factors that could be affecting their immune system. Nobody gets that education.
In functional medicine, the goal is to get an autoimmune disease into remission where it’s not active and not causing damage and destruction. In celiac disease, the goal is to be able to get those villi to come back healthy and strong so that they can absorb nutrients.
There’s a lot of turnover in gut cells, meaning that they rapidly grow, divide, and die. If somebody is actively working on their gut health, they’re going to create gradually healthier and healthier cells as the cells are turning over. It’s so important that we are fine-tuning everything that we can from a person’s diet to the microbiome to nutrients. We want to give the gut the ingredients to be able to heal better.
It could take a while to heal and repair the gut depending on how much damage was there and what needs to be modified. It could take months or longer.
Healing Gut Health in Celiac Disease and Gluten Sensitivity
At the Caplan Health Institute, we can show you how to strengthen your gut, whether you have celiac disease or gluten intolerance. Even in stubborn cases of celiac disease, we can help you get real relief and feel healthier by improving your nutrient absorption and gut microbiome. If you have gluten sensitivity, we can guide you through a gluten-free diet as well as identify any other roadblocks standing between you and your intestinal health so that eventually you may be able to tolerate limited amounts of gluten. Your symptoms will fade away and you’ll feel more energized, comfortable, and in control of your health.
The first step is to schedule a free 15-minute discovery consultation, by phone or video. If you decide to come on board as a practice member, we can order tests and create a personalized plan to stabilize your gut health. We call our patients “practice members” because they take an active role in their health.


Leave a Reply